Friday, July 06, 2012

frozen peanut butter butterfinger pie {pintertest kitchen}

{the winner of the sponsor giveaway is jurita! email me today to claim your goodies!}


long ago and far away, my friend jessica started this great project. pinterTest kitchen.

you know how we pin and pin things on pinterest? i mean, we pin amazingness.
but what do we do with those incredible boards of goodness?

i've tried several things i've pinned, but i don't know that i've ever recorded it much here.
so, for the first time ever, you get to see my pin come to life.

and kids, get ready, because this is a 100% pinter-tested winner:

i pinned this weeks ago. and i ain't lion, i think about it every other day.
i decided it was time to treat myself to some frozen pie excellence.

fact :: i love every single thing that i've made from kristan's blog.
and she's a gem herself! funny and fabulous all the way.

i gathered my ingredients, from target, because horrors! we didn't have any butterfingers in the house!

chocolate pre-made crust
8 oz block cream cheese, softened
1/2 of a 14 oz can of sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup peanut butter
1/4 cup powdered sugar
8 oz tub cool whip, thawed
8 fun size butterfinger candy bars, chopped

a little something i realized during all this? i hate pre-made crusts like this.
it was too stressful trying to keep it intact. surprisingly, it's held up well.

i mixed the cream cheese, condensed milk, peanut butter, and powdered sugar in my mixer bowl. 
then beat on medium until smooth and completely combined. next i folded in the cool whip and
the chopped butterfingers-i reserved a 1/4 cup for the top of the pie :) after pouring it into the crust,
i sprinkled my remaining candy on top and placed it in the freezer until firm.

ok. confession. i didn't wait until the pie was super frozen to try it. we couldn't wait long enough!
it was mostly firm, and it was totally delicious. creamy, rich and super sweet.
today i had a piece for after lunch and it was super frozen and of course, delicious.

i highly recommend this simple pie. in fact, come visit me, and i'll make you one!

have you baked, cooked or crafted anything from your pinterest boards lately?
link up with fancy jessica anytime this month and share!


if you're looking for a patriotic recap of july 4th, come back on monday

and get a post of your own ready to link up. details here or here!


  1. i'll be there on tuesday. noonish.


  2. I love you for this. for real. i HEART me some butterfinger!!!!!!

  3. Wowzers that looks amazing! I knew it would be the bomb ;)

  4. #1. that font alone is the reason i want to marry pic monkey. #2. 13 of those. coming right up. #3. i love your guts. thanks for linking up, friend! xxoo

  5. look at you linkin up all over the place.

    i'm putting this on the menu request list for when i visit.
    also, i wont require it to be fully frozen either. i'm with you. the sooner the better.
    i mean, the rapture could happen at any second right?


  6. i have been waiting for this kind of link up! i did a blog last month of all my pinterest experiments :) emailed you friend. i love giveaways :) big hugs little kiss.

  7. oh my!! my mouth is watering!! just wanted to let you know that I am blogging again :)

  8. Nom Nom!! I can't wait for an excuse to try this one!! It looks DELISH!!

  9. ok! i'll be on my way over! looks scrumptious!

  10. Well. I mean, you know Scott won't let me in the living room so I'm catching up on blogs. And I Ain't lion, this is amazing. And Kim's comment cracked me up.